Certified Proof Buffalo Nickels


Proof Buffalo Nickels were minted during the initial years of the series from 1913 to 1917. During these years, the coins were in matte proof. Proofs were minted once again in the two later years of the series 1936 to 1937. For the first of these years, coins were either matte proof or brilliant proof, while the second year has all brilliant proofs.

Below you will find a selection of Proof Buffalo Nickels which have been graded by NGC or PCGS.

1937 PCGS PR Genuine Buffalo Nickel Brilliant Proof Strike

1937 PCGS PR Genuine Buffalo Nickel Brilliant Proof Strike

- $807.49 8h 42m
1937 PCGS PR66+ Buffalo Nickel

1937 PCGS PR66+ Buffalo Nickel

- $1,750.00 17h 5m
1937 BUFFALO 5C PCGS PR 68

1937 BUFFALO 5C PCGS PR 68

- $15,700.00 23h 28m
1937 BUFFALO 5C PCGS PR 68

1937 BUFFALO 5C PCGS PR 68

- $7,900.00 1d 1h 7m
1936 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

1936 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

- $6,800.00 1d 2h 2m
1937 BUFFALO 5C PCGS PR 68

1937 BUFFALO 5C PCGS PR 68

- $7,900.00 1d 2h 9m
1915 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

1915 BUFFALO 5C NGC PR 68

- $21,000.00 1d 6h 36m
1936 PROOF Brilliant Buffalo Nickel 5C Coin - PCGS PR67 (PF67) - $3, 750 Value!

1936 PROOF Brilliant Buffalo Nickel 5C Coin - PCGS PR67 (PF67) - $3, 750 Value!

- $3,416.00 1d 8h 4m
1937 Buffalo Nickel 5c PR66 PCGS ~ CAC

1937 Buffalo Nickel 5c PR66 PCGS ~ CAC

- $1,450.00 1d 10h 46m
1937 Buffalo Nickel PCGS PR66 Superb Eye Appeal

1937 Buffalo Nickel PCGS PR66 Superb Eye Appeal

- $1,721.00 1d 11h 1m
1940 1C Lincoln Cent Proof PR66RD PCGS - CAC Pop Only 47

1940 1C Lincoln Cent Proof PR66RD PCGS - CAC Pop Only 47

- $358.95 1d 15h 54m
1937 Gem Proof Buffalo Nickel PCGS Certified PF66-Low Mintage Proof

1937 Gem Proof Buffalo Nickel PCGS Certified PF66-Low Mintage Proof

- $1,462.00 1d 22h 19m
1937 Buffalo Nickel PCGS PR-66

1937 Buffalo Nickel PCGS PR-66

- $1,416.45 1d 23h 34m
1936 5C Buffalo Nickel Brilliant PCGS PR66 CAC

1936 5C Buffalo Nickel Brilliant PCGS PR66 CAC

- $2,000.00 3d 15h 2m
1914 Buffalo nickel,  PCGS PR67 razor sharp,  totally original B9332

1914 Buffalo nickel, PCGS PR67 razor sharp, totally original B9332

- $4,100.00 3d 18h 14m
1936 5C Proof Buffalo Nickel Type 2 - PCGS PR66 Gold CAC Approved - OGH

1936 5C Proof Buffalo Nickel Type 2 - PCGS PR66 Gold CAC Approved - OGH

- $3,600.00 3d 18h 27m
1937 Proof Buffalo Nickel certified PF 65 by NGC! A mintage of just 5769!

1937 Proof Buffalo Nickel certified PF 65 by NGC! A mintage of just 5769!

- $1,099.00 4d 19h 5m
1937 Buffalo Nickel PCGS PR65 Great Eye Appeal

1937 Buffalo Nickel PCGS PR65 Great Eye Appeal

- $1,506.00 6d 3h 33m