Certified Proof Buffalo Nickels


Proof Buffalo Nickels were minted from 1913 to 1917. During these years, the coins were in matte proof. Proofs were minted once again in the final two years of the series 1937 to 1938. In 1937 there were some satin proof and brilliant proof coins.

Below you will find a selection of Proof Buffalo Nickels which have been graded by NGC or PCGS.

Buffalo Nickels - Lot of 20 -Private Collection 1925-37

Buffalo Nickels - Lot of 20 -Private Collection 1925-37

1 $0.99 1d 20h 22m
Buffalo Nickels - Lot of 20 -Private Collection 1926-37

Buffalo Nickels - Lot of 20 -Private Collection 1926-37

2 $3.25 1d 20h 25m
1937  BUFFALO NICKEL--PROOFLIKE-- QUALITY U.S. COIN

1937 BUFFALO NICKEL--PROOFLIKE-- QUALITY U.S. COIN

1 $0.99 2d 21h 17m
Buffalo Nickel NGC PROOF 4 COIN SET 1913 1914 1936 1937

Buffalo Nickel NGC PROOF 4 COIN SET 1913 1914 1936 1937

$9,995.00 3d 9h 53m
1936 BUFFALO FIVE CENTS SATIN PCGS PR64

1936 BUFFALO FIVE CENTS SATIN PCGS PR64

$1,450.00 4d 2h 25m
1937 BUFFALO FIVE CENTS PCGS PR66

1937 BUFFALO FIVE CENTS PCGS PR66

$1,675.00 4d 2h 25m
1937 5C BUFFALO NICKEL PROOF PCGS PR66

1937 5C BUFFALO NICKEL PROOF PCGS PR66

- $1,900.00 4d 21h 54m
1937 Buffalo Nickel NGC PF 67 Mintage 5, 769!

1937 Buffalo Nickel NGC PF 67 Mintage 5, 769!

$2,899.99 7d 22h 24m
1915 Buffalo PCGS PROOF 67 PR67

1915 Buffalo PCGS PROOF 67 PR67

$5,750.00 10d 1h 45m
1914  PROOF 67 PR67 NGC GRADED BUFFALO NICKEL

1914 PROOF 67 PR67 NGC GRADED BUFFALO NICKEL

$4,750.00 10d 1h 49m
USA US  COIN 5 CENTS 1914 D  UNC PROOF LIKE

USA US COIN 5 CENTS 1914 D UNC PROOF LIKE

$500.00 11d 17h 37m
USA US  COIN 5 CENTS 1915 D  AU+  PROOF LIKE

USA US COIN 5 CENTS 1915 D AU+ PROOF LIKE

$180.00 11d 17h 40m